Interconnector resistance far more than ‘some local opposition’

A CALL on the Government to commission a genuinely independent assessment of undergrounding the North-South Interconnector, was made in the Dail last week.

Making the call, Deputy Darren O'Rourke warned that attempting to force through the controversial overhead route would not deliver the project.

Addressing the Minister of State for Environment in the Dáil, Deputy O’Rourke said the Government continues to dismiss the strength of opposition among communities in Meath, despite the issue having been the subject of concern and controversy for almost two decades.

Minister Dillons said that Eirgrid as the project developer, had been engaging and continued to engage with the affected landowners and communities along the route. "This is in line with what the Government expects of EirGrid and is aligned with the 2012 Government policy statement on the strategic importance of transmission and other energy infrastructure," he said.

Speaking afterwards, Deputy O’Rourke said; "The Minister of State described opposition to this project as 'some local opposition'. That is a complete understatement. There is massive local opposition to the proposed overhead route, and the Government needs to recognise that.

"Communities in Meath and beyond have been raising serious concerns about this project for years. They are not opposed to strengthening our electricity infrastructure or improving energy security. "Their concerns relate to how this project is being delivered and, in particular, the Government’s refusal to properly address the underground alternative.

"The Government continues to point to previous reports as justification for proceeding with overhead pylons. However, the most recent report does not conclude that undergrounding is not viable. In fact, it is highly critical of EirGrid and the way it has conducted its analysis over the years.

"I challenged the Minister of State on this directly in the Dáil. I asked him to read the short report himself rather than simply relying on the Department’s interpretation of it.

"We need a genuinely independent assessment of the overhead and underground options, one that properly examines the technical, environmental, financial and community impacts of both approaches.

"I am convinced that if that assessment is undertaken properly, it will demonstrate that undergrounding is a viable option and provide a way forward for this project.

"It is also deeply concerning that the Government has extended powers under the Critical Infrastructure Act to accelerate projects of this nature. Using additional powers to push ahead in the face of such significant local opposition is completely the wrong approach.

"EirGrid has a very poor track record in how it has handled this particular project. The Government cannot simply outsource its responsibility to EirGrid and expect communities to accept whatever decision it makes.

"This project will not be successfully delivered by attempting to force it through. There needs to be trust, transparency and meaningful engagement with the people who will be directly affected.

"The North-South Interconnector is important infrastructure. But that does not mean that the Government should abandon proper scrutiny or ignore legitimate concerns about how it is delivered.

"There is a way forward. It involves an independent assessment of overhead versus undergrounding. If the Government refuses to address that fundamental issue, we are on the road to nowhere," he said.

"I will continue to press the Government to revisit the project and ensure the concerns of affected communities in Meath and elsewhere are properly addressed."

Minister of State at the Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment, Alan Dillon, said the North-South interconnector was one of the most important electricity transmission projects under way in the State. "The Government fully supports its delivery. It will link the electricity networks of Ireland and Northern Ireland, leading to more secure, affordable and sustainable supply of electricity across the island. The European network of transmission system operators currently estimates that the project will deliver a cost saving of €120 million per annum to households and businesses across the island of Ireland by 2040.

"The North-South interconnector is an excellent example of the critical infrastructure that the Government is determined to accelerate. In July, the Government designated the North-South interconnector, along with Moneypoint's 400 kV series capacitor and the Letterkenny 110 kV station redevelopment as critical infrastructure under the Critical Infrastructure Act. Since their designations, the Moneypoint and Letterkenny projects have both received grants of planning and are progressing towards delivery.

"The North-South interconnector is awaiting a decision from the relevant local authorities in respect of the discharge of planning conditions. Having engaged directly with the council on the criticality of the project, I am aware that acceleration efforts are under way to include the appointment of a project co-ordinator.

"I look forward to the start of construction of this project once the planning condition has been discharged.

"I am, that there is some local opposition to the project and in particular to the fact it is being delivered as an overhead line. EirGrid, as the project developer, has determined the project must be delivered as an overhead line and the Government has accepted the expert opinion. The notion of undergrounding the project has been comprehensively assessed on several occasions dating back to 2008, with corresponding independent reports published finding an overhead line is the most appropriate means of delivery. Most recently, in March 2023 the Government noted and published an independent report into the project that concluded it was not feasible to run the North-South interconnector underground, thereby confirming the 2018 report remains valid."