Political will needed for solution to personal bank debt

Although his controversial comments last week may have been rather colourful coming from a senior court figure, what Master of the High Court Edmund Honohan had to say about the banks and their pursuit of borrowers in trouble will have struck a chord with many in Irish society. It is not difficult to see how he had been moved to make such comments, given the level of personal indebtedness he sees in court each week. Mr Honohan suggested that people were being 'driven to suicide' by banks and creditors pursuing debts to the bitter end. He added that the banks had been 'cheerleaders' for the Celtic Tiger and, now that the bubble had burst, they had reverted to type. He went on to call for a measure of debt forgiveness for hard-pressed borrowers who are unable to repay their debts in full. The frustration of sitting in court and hearing the stories and pleas from desperate homeowners clinging to a roof over their heads was evident in his remarks. Over three years after Ireland's credit-fuelled bubble burst with such catastrophic consequences for the economy and Irish society as a whole, we still have seen no reform of the country's antiquated personal debt laws. Virtually uniquely in the western world, debtors here can be jailed if they fail to repay the money which they owe. Those declared bankrupt also face extreme restrictions for 12 years, even if they have not acted recklessly in their business. In the UK, people in the same position face sanctions lasting just 12 months. Now, even the Catholic Church has come out in support of Edmund Honohan, calling on the banks to recognise that the family home cannot be treated like any other property, and that the risk of losing a home should not be underestimated or minimised. In a clear endorsement of Mr Honohan's views in relation to some banks' aggressive and relentless pursuit of distressed debtors, Bishop Raymond Field, chairperson of the Bishops' Council for Justice and Peace, said priority has to be given to finding a just, viable and sustainable solution for homeowners in arrears, in the interests of the common good. Progress on reform has been miniscule as a result of the lack of a comprehensive government approach. FLAC's director-general Noeline Blackwell said it appeared the government still had to come to grips with the absolute urgency of the need for reform in this area now. "Right now, people who are over-indebted must grapple with a court system which is never going to actually solve their problem and where all the power still lies with the lender. Banks will say that they are engaging with debtors, but they still can do this in whatever way this suits their agenda. Any sustainable solution will involve a number of sections of government coming together and coming up with an overall solution," she said. There have long been calls to tackle the lack of an effective legal system for people who are seriously over-indebted and to change an antiquated legal system which is not fit for purpose in the current recession. Similar calls have been made by a range of organisations including the Law Reform Commission, the Irish Banking Federation and even the IMF. The technical work has largely been done through the efforts of the Law Reform Commission but what is required now is the political will to implement a solution - and do it quickly. The government has said it is taking a fresh look at banking policy and bankruptcy laws. But debt forgiveness on a wide scale is unlikely, given the difficulties that would be created by writing off the debt of one person but asking another to continue paying their debts. Ultimately, banks and their customers will have to work through any difficulties themselves. However, changing the laws governing this area and weighting them more fairly towards the borrower in difficulty would send a signal to those buried under a mountain of debt they are unable to pay that they will not be left swinging in the wind and that there can be a resolution to their difficulties.